Understanding examples of reasonable accommodation under the Fair Housing Act is vital for every HOA board. These requests come up more often than people think, and mismanaging them can land a community in hot water.
Reasonable Accommodation Examples: Understanding the FHA and ADA
In many ways, homeowners associations and condo communities work like small towns. They set rules, manage the property, and keep things running. Just as federal laws govern small towns, associations are also subject to specific federal laws, especially those related to discrimination.
Both the Fair Housing Act (FHA) and Americans With Disabilities Act (ADA) can apply to associations. While the former covers housing discrimination, the latter primarily concerns discrimination in public spaces (open to non-residents).
The distinction can get confusing, especially for self-managed boards. Basically, the FHA applies to all housing, even HOAs and condo associations. Meanwhile, the latter covers only spaces or facilities open to the general public.
If a clubhouse is private, meaning only residents and their guests use it, the ADA probably doesn’t apply. That said, if the same clubhouse can be rented to the public, the ADA may apply. In this case, the association must ensure it meets accessibility standards.
Both the FHA and ADA can overlap in some instances. Because of this, boards need to know which one applies before they act.
Fair Housing Act
The Fair Housing Act protects people from discrimination based on disability, race, religion, sex, or family status. In an association, this means no one must be subjected to any unfair treatment based on the listed classes. It also means that associations must accommodate a resident if necessary. This can include changing a rule for them or allowing a modification.
Americans With Disabilities Act
What homeowners and managers need to know about ADA is that it mainly covers public access. In HOAs and condos, it usually applies only to parts of the property that outsiders use. This includes things like a leasing office or a clubhouse that hosts public events.
What Does Reasonable Accommodation Mean?
When it comes to HOA reasonable accommodations, these are changes in the rules or services that let someone with a disability enjoy their home in the same way. Board members should not view this as special treatment. It is more about making sure someone has equal use of their home.
It is important to remember that accommodations are not the same as modifications. A modification usually means physically changing something, like building a ramp. An accommodation, on the other hand, is about policy changes, like allowing a caregiver to live on-site. Both can be required under the FHA, depending on what someone needs.
Under the law, an association must approve a request if it’s reasonable and doesn’t cause major financial or administrative problems. If it’s too expensive, unsafe, or would totally change how the HOA works, the board can deny it.
That said, the board needs a valid reason. It must also have solid documentation to support its denial. If there is any personal or medical information involved, this must remain confidential.
Common Reasonable Accommodation Examples
Many examples of FHA and ADA accommodations show what “reasonable” actually looks like. Each one depends on the person’s needs, the type of association, and how the board handles it.
Here are some common examples of reasonable accommodations.
1. Service and Support Animals
One of the most common examples of a reasonable accommodation involves animals. The FHA allows both service and emotional support animals, even in communities with a “no-pets” policy.
Service animals are trained to perform tasks, such as guiding someone or alerting them to danger. Emotional support animals don’t need special training, but they still qualify under the FHA because they help with mental or emotional stability. The ADA, on the other hand, only covers trained service animals.
Boards can ask for simple proof, such as a letter from a doctor or therapist. That said, they can’t dig into someone’s medical records or charge pet deposits for service or support animals. They can deny a request only if the animal is dangerous, damages property, or the paperwork doesn’t check out.
2. Accessible Parking Spaces
Another big one for HOA accommodations for disabled residents is parking. Someone with mobility issues might ask for a closer spot or one reserved specifically for them. Even if the association already has ADA-compliant parking, the HOA may still need to grant this request.
The point isn’t about whether the community has accessible spaces in general. Instead, it’s about whether the person making the request can reasonably access their home. Parking is a shared accommodation, and boards should handle it carefully.
3. Physical Modifications in Units and Common Areas
Some reasonable accommodation examples involve physical changes, too. These include grab bars in bathrooms, ramps near stairs, or wider doorways.
Homeowners usually handle the cost of private unit modifications. On the other hand, the HOA covers the cost for those in common areas. Keep in mind that associations can’t collect a special fee just because someone requested a change related to their disability. This is against FHA rules.
4. Adjustments to Rules and Policies
Not every request needs tools or construction. Sometimes, the problem lies in the community’s rules. If a policy keeps a resident from safely using their home, the board should consider changing it. These are the easiest accommodations to make and usually cost nothing.
5. Communication and Assistance Requests
Communication counts, too. Some residents might ask for notices in large print or by email rather than by paper mail. Others might need a board member to read aloud. These reasonable accommodation examples ensure fair communication for everyone.
When can HOAs Deny a Reasonable Accommodation Request?
Associations don’t need to approve every request. The FHA allows boards to deny a request if it causes an unreasonable financial or administrative burden. The same applies if it poses a safety risk or changes the HOA’s operations.
For example, asking the HOA to build an elevator for one unit or hire a full-time helper for a resident isn’t reasonable. Still, boards can’t just deny a request and move on. They need to talk it through with the resident and see if another option works.
How to Ask HOA for a Reasonable Accommodation
Residents should make requests in writing to ensure a clear record or paper trail. There is no FHA-mandated form, but it’s still best to provide complete information. For this reason, the association should develop a standard form that asks the resident about their need and the reasons for it. If the need isn’t apparent, the HOA can ask for proof, but only enough to verify the claim.
After the resident files a request, the HOA should start the process. This involves having a conversation to figure out what works best for the resident making the request. It is important to remain respectful throughout all of this and to ensure that all personal or medical information remains private.
To standardize everything, communities should have written policies covering reasonable accommodation requests. This will help keep things fair and consistent. It will also help the association avoid trouble later on.
Learn to Ask for Help
Board members should understand the examples of reasonable accommodations under the FHA and ADA. This will help them ensure compliance and keep things fair for everyone. Cases aren’t always cut-and-dry, so it is best to seek legal advice when things get blurry.
Hillcrest offers HOA management services to communities in Chicago. Call us today at 630-627-3303 or contact us online to request a proposal!
RELATED ARTICLES:
- What Is The Open Meeting Act in HOAs?
- Chicago IL HOA Laws: A Guide For The Board And Homeowners
- What Is Conflict Of Interest In HOA And COA Boards?
