Can an HOA charge legal fees to homeowners? When an owner receives a bill for legal costs from their HOA, they often wonder whether the association has the authority to do so. In Illinois, review state laws before taking further action.

 

Can HOA Charge Legal Fees to Homeowner?

In Illinois, an HOA can charge legal fees to homeowners under certain circumstances.

Associations will sometimes incur attorney fees when collecting unpaid dues, enforcing the rules, or resolving disputes. While these expenses can be passed on to individual owners, the board can’t do so whenever it wants. The board must have a valid legal basis.

 

Can HOA Charge Homeowners Legal Fees in Illinois?can hoa charge homeowners legal fees

If state laws and the governing documents allow it, an HOA can charge legal fees to homeowners in Illinois. Still, it depends on the type of association and the specific statute that governs it.

 

Homeowners Associations

The Illinois Common Interest Community Association Act primarily governs HOAs in the state.

Under 765 ILCS 160/1-30, an HOA should not treat attorney fees and court or arbitration costs in the same way as other collection fees. This statute does not, by itself, give every HOA unlimited authority to charge legal expenses to homeowners.

For further guidance, HOA boards must review their governing documents, particularly the CC&Rs and bylaws, for any provisions on charging legal fees to an individual owner.

 

Condominiums

The Illinois Condominium Property Act governs condo associations in the state. This statute includes more specific provisions on charging attorney fees to unit owners.

Under 765 ILCS 605/9.2, condominiums can add attorney fees to an owner’s dues or assessments if the fees arise from that owner’s default. This can also include violations involving the owner, their tenant, or a guest.

 

Can HOA Charge Attorney Fees?

If state laws and the governing documents allow it, an HOA can charge attorney fees to individual homeowners in Illinois. That said, simply involving an attorney does not automatically make the owner responsible for paying those fees.

 

When Can an HOA Charge Legal Fees to Homeowners?

The specific circumstances can determine whether an HOA can pass legal expenses on to a homeowner, but common situations typically involve unpaid HOA dues, violations of HOA rules, and lawsuits against homeowners.

 

1. Unpaid HOA Dues

Homeowners must pay regular dues and any approved special assessments to the association. When an owner falls behind, the association may need legal assistance to collect the outstanding balance.

Most HOAs hire an attorney for the job. An attorney can prepare demand letters, negotiate payment terms, or pursue collection through the courts. The HOA may be able to recover these legal expenses if state laws or its governing documents allow.

 

2. Violations of HOA Rules

Associations enforce rules to maintain order and protect the community. When homeowners violate these rules, the board may take enforcement action, such as levying fines and suspending privileges.

While violations can vary, common ones typically include unapproved architectural changes, improper parking, or lack of property maintenance. Some disputes become so dire that they eventually require legal action. This usually happens when an owner simply refuses to correct their violation.

Condominium associations can generally charge the owner for attorney fees incurred in enforcing rules. Meanwhile, HOAs must refer to their governing documents to confirm if the same is permitted.

 

3. Lawsuits Against Homeowners

Sometimes, an association must file a lawsuit to enforce its governing documents or collect unpaid fees. These lawsuits can be quite expensive, with the association incurring attorney fees, court filing fees, and other costs. If the legal proceedings escalate to litigation, expenses can inflate even more.

An association may recover some of these expenses from the homeowner, provided state laws, the governing documents, or a court order says so. Keep in mind that filing a lawsuit does not automatically make the owner responsible for covering these costs.

If the association loses the lawsuit, a court may even order the HOA to pay the owner’s legal fees. Conversely, if the association wins, a court may order HOA attorney fees charged to the homeowner.

 

Can an HOA Charge Any Amount for Legal Fees?

An association can’t charge just any amount for legal fees.

Even in situations where an HOA can pass legal fees to an owner, the amount must be reasonable. A court may even intervene and review reasonableness.

For example, in Claymoor Condominium Association v. Majewska (2024), an Illinois appellate court examined factors such as attorney billing records, hourly rates, services performed, and the nature of the dispute. To ensure accuracy, board members should keep records of the invoices and other legal expenses related to the case.

Associations should not treat this as an opportunity to profit from attorney fees or impose excessive charges. Moreover, boards should never use this to retaliate against an owner who questions the board’s decisions. Retaliation is never the answer.

 

What Happens If a Homeowner Refuses to Pay Legal Fees?HOA attorney fees charged to homeowner

If a homeowner refuses to pay valid legal fees, an association can pursue certain collection remedies depending on the type of community.

For condominiums, 765 ILCS 605/9 allows the association to include reasonable attorney fees in a lien against the unit. On the other hand, HOAs must rely on their governing documents and lien rights.

Some boards may instinctively want to take legal action, but that will only complicate things. It is best to exhaust all other options before escalating the dispute, which can result in even more legal fees.

 

Can HOA Charge Legal Fees? Best Practices to Follow

In general, an association can charge legal fees to homeowners if state laws and the governing documents allow it. That said, boards must establish and follow certain practices to make the process valid and smooth.

 

1. Review the Governing Documents

First, the HOA board must review the CC&Rs and bylaws, along with collection policies, before charging attorney fees. These documents may consist of specific provisions dictating when the board can charge legal expenses and how.

 

2. Follow Proper Collection Procedures

Associations must follow due process when collecting unpaid balances. Typically, this includes providing notice. Under 765 ILCS 160/1-45, associations must even adopt a written collection policy and follow it before taking legal action.

 

3. Maintain Accurate Records

Proper documentation can help support every charge that an HOA passes on to the owner. Boards should keep records of attorney invoices, account statements, correspondence, and decisions.

 

4. Consult an HOA Attorney

An experienced HOA attorney can help the board navigate legal issues and fees. They can also help prevent unnecessary disputes.

 

Can HOA Charge Legal Fees to Homeowners? Answered!

Legal fees can accumulate with every unpaid fee or rule violation that an HOA takes action on. An association can generally pass on these charges to the owner, provided state laws and the governing documents allow.

Managing an HOA in Chicago doesn’t have to be difficult. Let Hillcrest take care of the daily work with our professional HOA management services. Get started by calling 630-627-3303 or requesting a proposal online!

 

RELATED ARTICLES: